In 2019, a couple paid $1.5 million for a 2.5-acre lot at 3 Cherry Hills Park Drive. They spent three years building a 22,500-square-foot house there, with five bedrooms, 10 bathrooms and more than 13,000 square feet of finished living space. In February 2026 the house was listed at $18 million, according to BusinessDen. In October it sold for $15.8 million. BusinessDen ranked that sale as metro Denver's most expensive home sale of the month.
That one property contains three different prices. There is the 2019 price of the dirt, the cost of three years of construction, and the gap between the asking price and the final sale. The other Cherry Hills Village sales that made the metro's monthly top-five lists in 2026 split along the same lines. Read address by address, they show a pattern a median would hide. In this year's top tier, the most expensive housing per square foot was the oldest and smallest house in the group, and the price per foot dropped as the houses got bigger. The new build and the 1941 house, the two ends of the age range, each sold $2.2 million below their asking prices, while the houses in between sold close to theirs.
Five sales, one year
Each sale below was reported in BusinessDen's or The Denver Post's monthly roundups of the metro's priciest closings. The price per square foot is our own arithmetic from the reported sale price and square footage.
| Address | Month sold, 2026 | Sale price | Built | Reported size | Price per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Cherry Hills Drive | March | $9.8M | 1941 | 6,000 sq ft on 3.7 acres | about $1,633 |
| 49 Sunset Drive | April | $10.3M | renovated from the studs | 10,869 sq ft on 3+ acres | about $948 |
| 4800 S. Lafayette Lane | June | $7.4M | 1986 | 8,084 sq ft | about $915 |
| 6 Lynn Road | June | $8M | 2015 | 11,787 sq ft | about $679 |
| 3 Cherry Hills Park Drive | October | $15.8M | new, on a lot bought in 2019 | 22,500 sq ft, 13,000+ finished, on 2.5 acres | about $702 gross |
The 6,000-square-foot house sold for the most per foot, and the two houses above 11,000 square feet sold for the least. A buyer comparing Cherry Hills Village listings by price per square foot, the way they might compare condos downtown, would read this table backward.
The 1941 house on the 10th fairway was priced as land
11 Cherry Hills Drive came to market in November 2025 for the first time in nearly 70 years. BusinessDen reported a $12 million asking price for a New England-style manor built in 1941. The house is 6,000 square feet, with five bedrooms and six baths. It sits on 3.7 acres and has 841 linear feet of frontage along the 10th fairway of Cherry Hills Country Club. One family bought it in 1958 and updated it in the 1990s, adding an elevator while keeping its character. The grounds include a pool, a pool house, gardens and century-old trees.
BusinessDen reported that it sold in March for $9.8 million, the top sale in the Denver area that month. That works out to about $1,633 per square foot of house, or about $2.65 million per acre. A 6,000-square-foot house from 1941 does not reach that figure on its rooms. The buyer paid for 3.7 acres on the fairway, the frontage and the trees, and the house came along with them. The $2.2 million gap between the $12 million asking price and the sale price was the market's answer to how much more a decades-old home was worth on top of the land.
New work set the highest prices, then met the negotiation
The two highest-priced sales on the list are the ones where someone had just put money into the structure.
At 49 Sunset Drive, CHV Home Inc., a family-run Colorado company that transforms high-end homes, bought the property in November 2024 for $3.8 million. It renovated the gated estate from the studs up, adding a chef's kitchen, natural stone finishes, an elevator, a full bar, a home theater and a golf simulator. BusinessDen reported the April sale at $10.3 million, the highest-priced home sale in the Denver area that month. The Denver Post described the property as more than three acres with 10,869 square feet. The $6.5 million spread between purchase and resale is a gross figure, before the cost of that renovation.
3 Cherry Hills Park Drive sold for $702 per gross square foot, or no more than about $1,215 per finished foot, which is still well below the 1941 house on Cherry Hills Drive. It also sold $2.2 million below its February asking price. That is the same dollar gap as 11 Cherry Hills Drive, on a larger base. In its October roundup, The Denver Post singled out the house's 2,000-pound steel front door. Bold architecture appeals to buyers who share the builder's taste. Buyers who don't share it adjust their offer.
The same pattern showed up at the very top of the market late in 2025. BusinessDen reported that 4603 S. Denice Drive, a 22,000-square-foot house on two acres, sold for $17 million in November 2025 after first listing at $20 million. In Cherry Hills Village's biggest houses, the gap between asking price and sale price was measured in millions.
A $1.5 million lot in 2019 became a $15.8 million sale in 2026, and a $3.8 million purchase in 2024 became $10.3 million in 2026. The buyer at the end paid for land plus the finished house, and the asking-price gap on Cherry Hills Park Drive shows how much room there was to negotiate over the value one owner's vision added to the land.
The proven houses sold closest to asking
The two June sales are the quietest entries on the list, and they cleared closest to their asking prices.
6 Lynn Road was built in 2015 and has 11,787 square feet, six bedrooms, nine bathrooms, a wine cellar, a private library and a south-facing primary suite with mountain views. BusinessDen reported that the sellers bought it in 2018 for $4.9 million, listed it for $7.8 million in April 2026, and sold it for $8 million in June. It is the only sale here known to have closed above its asking price, and at about $679 per square foot it was the least expensive per foot of the five.
4800 S. Lafayette Lane in Old Cherry Hills was built in 1986 by Denver's Harrison Custom Homes. It has 8,084 square feet, a white marble kitchen island and a renovated guest house with a fireplace and wet bar. It sold June 24 for $7.4 million, just under its $7.6 million asking price.
What these two have in common is age without antiquity. The Lynn Road house was about a decade old when it sold, and the Lafayette Lane house had been updated. Neither asked a buyer to pay for a rebuild that had just finished, and neither asked a buyer to look past the house to the land under it. Each was priced as a house that works, and each sold within a few percent of its asking price.
Why this matters when you compare listings
Put the five sales next to each other and a Cherry Hills Village price turns out to be one of three things.
- Land with a house on it. 11 Cherry Hills Drive is the 2026 example. The acreage, the frontage and the setting set the price, and the house's age is visible in how far the sale fell below the asking price.
- Land plus new construction or a full renovation. 3 Cherry Hills Park Drive and 49 Sunset Drive are the examples. These were the two highest prices of the year and posted the largest gross gains over their entry cost. 3 Cherry Hills Park Drive also sold $2.2 million under its asking price.
- A house the market already knows how to value. 6 Lynn Road and 4800 S. Lafayette Lane sold closest to their asking prices.
A buyer who knows which of the three they are looking at can tell whether a $1,600-per-foot asking price is high or normal for that kind of property, and whether a new build's asking price leaves room to negotiate. A seller can use the same reading to decide whether money spent on the house before listing will come back, or whether the land is already doing most of the work. Our earlier post on pricing a luxury home in Cherry Hills Village covers the seller's side of that decision.
The next lot is already on the map
The first kind of sale, land with a house on it, is the one that produces the next round of the second kind. The supply of land in the Village shifted this spring. In May 2026, Cherry Hills Village City Council voted to split the 4.9-acre lot at 1 Cherry Hills Park Drive in half at its owners' request, BusinessDen reported, giving one of the Village's most exclusive pockets room for one more home. That is the street where a $1.5 million lot from 2019 became a $15.8 million sale this October. A new parcel there is a new starting point for the cycle in the middle row of the list above, and it will eventually add another new-build price to these comparisons.
If you are weighing a Cherry Hills Village property and want to know whether its price is paying for the land, the construction or a proven house, Downing Street Group can walk through the 2026 comparable sales with you, address by address. Request a private consultation, or start with a confidential home valuation if you own in the Village and want to know which kind of sale yours would be.